CNC Machining Services » News » Stainless Steel vs Aluminum: What are the Differences?

Stainless Steel vs Aluminum: What are the Differences?

Stainless steel and aluminum are among the many two hottest manufacturing materials in engineering. Their bodily and mechanical properties make them appropriate for various manufacturing functions. Moreover, each are very appropriate with a number of manufacturing strategies, reminiscent of machining, casting, sheet metal fabrication, and so forth. Nevertheless, there are a number of variations between Stainless steel Vs Aluminum, from their properties, functions, price, and different elements.In case you are on this comparability, be until the tip. We are going to focus on the variations between them intimately.

What’s Stainless Steel?

All steels are made by including different components to the iron materials, reminiscent of nickel, chromium, carbon, and sulfur. Stainless steel has an alloy composition of iron, with chromium  10.5% or above, lower than 30% nickel, and different metals like molybdenum in some instances. The chromium content material in stainless steel is significant in its corrosion-resistance property; it types a refractory oxide protecting layer on the surface to isolate the free irons from environmental oxygen. This materials is available in Stainless Steel Sheets , bars, blocks, and different types.Stainless Steel vs Aluminum: What are the Differences? Furthermore, the alternation within the composition of chromium, nickel, and different alloying objects ends in totally different grades of stainless steel with distinctive bodily and mechanical properties.The next desk reveals the frequent classes of stainless steel, their composition, included grade, and different traits.Desk: Stainless Steel Classes and Grades 
Steel ClassComposition (wt%)HardenableFerromagnetismGrades
MartensiticC: >0.10, Cr: 11-14, Ni: 0-1, Mo: 0-2, Others: VSureMagnetic410, 420, 431
C: >0.17, Cr: 16-18, Ni: 0-1, Mo: 0-2, Others: VSureMagnetic440C, 403, 414
Martensitic-AusteniticC: <0.10, Cr: 12-18, Ni: 4-6, Mo: 1-2SureMagnetic630 (17-4 PH), 2205
Precipitation HardeningC: -, Cr: 15-17, Ni: 7-8, Mo: 0-2, Others: Al, Cu, Ti, NbSureMagnetic17-4 PH, 15-5 PH
C: -, Cr: 12-17, Ni: 4-8, Mo: 0-2, Others: Al, Cu, Ti, NbSureMagnetic13-8 Mo, PH 13-8 Mo
FerriticC: <0.12, Cr: 10.5-27, Ni: 0-1, Mo: 0-4, Others: Nb, TiNoMagnetic409, 430, 439
AusteniticC: <0.10, Cr: 16-26, Ni: 6-22, Mo: 0-7, Others: N, MnNoNon-magnetic304, 316, 310S
DuplexC: <0.03, Cr: 18-28, Ni: 4.5-8, Mo: 1-4, Others: NNoMagnetic2205, 2507, 2101
Understanding the professionals & cons of every metal is important to match Stainless Steel vs Aluminum. So, let’s objectively level out the benefits of stainless steel first;

Advantages of Stainless Steel

Shiny Silver EndStainless Steel vs Aluminum: What are the Differences?Stainless steel seems shiny and silver-like. Machined or manufactured parts will be completed with methods like grinding or sprucing to customize the looks for a selective mirror end.Corrosion & Put on ResistanceOne of many fundamental causes behind stainless steel’s recognition is its corrosion and put on resistance benefits. The chromium and molybdenum composition considerably enhances this means. Stainless steel 316 is named a extremely corrosion-resistant grade. Moreover, the elevated hardness and power contribute to put on resistance. The truth is, it’s extra resistant than different steel, Alloy vs Stainless Steel, software steel, and carbon steel.Affect ResistanceAmongst varied glorious mechanical properties, excessive tensile power is one. Stainless steel withstands heavy hundreds, excessive pressures, and excessive temperatures. Thus, they can be utilized in structural functions and high-stress environments.Hygiene and CleanlinessThe non-porous nature of stainless steel alloys makes them straightforward to scrub, stopping bacterial development and contamination. That’s why they’re most well-liked in functions the place hygiene is essential, reminiscent of meals processing, pharmaceutical, and medical.

Disadvantages of Stainless Steel

  • The low thermal conductivity can harden shortly throughout machining, which will increase software put on.
  • Stainless steel is extra appropriate for chloride cracking, dents, and pits.
  • The decrease thermal conductivity restricts its use in some thermal functions like warmth sinks or different warmth dissipation merchandise.
  • It’s heavier than different metals, particularly when evaluating stainless steel vs aluminium.

What’s Aluminum?

Stainless Steel vs Aluminum: What are the Differences? Aluminum is probably the most ample metal on earth, and you’ll predict how huge the makes use of of this metal are in modern-day manufacturing. Not solely the supply, the excessive strength-to-weight ratio, corrosion resistance, mechanical power, electrical & thermal conductivity, and capability to create alloys with customized properties make it worthwhile in various functions.The frequent alloying components are copper, zinc, magnesium, and silicone. Including copper improves the mechanical power, magnesium additional reduces the burden, and silicone is value including if the aluminum goes to be cast.Desk: Aluminum Alloys & Grades 
SequenceCompositionHardenableKey PropertiesFrequent Grades
1xxxTremendous-purity and commercial-purity aluminiumNoGlorious corrosion resistance, excessive electrical conductivity1100, 1050
3xxxAl-Mn and AlMn-Mg alloysNoGood corrosion resistance, reasonable power3003, 3105
5xxxAl-Mg alloysNoExcessive power, good corrosion resistance5052, 5083, 5754
8xxxMiscellaneous alloysNoVaries (specialised properties for particular functions)8011, 8090
2xxxAl-Cu and AlCu-Mg alloysSureExcessive power, good machinability2024, 2011
6xxxAl-Mg-Si alloysSureGood power, good corrosion resistance6061, 6063
7xxxAl-Zn-Mg and Al-Zn-Mg-Cu alloysSureVery excessive power, good fatigue resistance7075, 705
 Moreover, let’s objectively checklist the benefits of aluminum  relative to stainless steel;

Advantages of Aluminum

Light-weightStainless Steel vs Aluminum: What are the Differences?One in every of aluminum’s fundamental benefits is its light-weight; its particular weight is 2.71 g/cm3. The mixture of upper power and light-weight makes aluminium alloys worthwhile in automotive, aerospace, electronics, and different light-weight functions.Flexibility with Manufacturing ProcessesFirst, aluminium is excellently machineable for CNC and different applied sciences. Moreover, aluminium alloys are appropriate with manufacturing processes reminiscent of die casting, forging, extrusion, and sheet metal methods.Thermal & Electrical ConductivityAluminium alloys have good thermal and electrical conductivity. Consequently, they’re broadly utilized in thermal and electrical functions like warmth sinks, electrical connectors, wiring, and so forth.Pure Al, 1xx sequence;
  • Thermal conductivity: 237 W m−1 Ok−1
  • Electrical conductivity: 33.3 x 107 S/m.
Corrosion ResistanceAluminium types its oxides whereas interreacting with moisture, which prevents materials degradation and improves the sturdiness of parts & merchandise. Moreover, it’s also a hygienic materials by nature.

Disadvantages of Aluminum

  • Aluminium’s cumulative power just isn’t as excessive as that of stainless steel so
  • it may be wrapped, cracked, or scratched with excessive stress.
  • Aluminium alloys are additionally costlier than different typical manufacturing materials.
  • Welding aluminium parts or sheets is troublesome and requires particular tools and tooling.
 

What Are the Variations Between Aluminum and Stainless Steel?

Now, it’s time for a head-to-head comparability of aluminum vs stainless steel. Let’s examine these two materials when it comes to their properties, machinability,  price, weldability, and different features.
  1. Power & Weight 
The power of stainless steel materials is increased than that of aluminum alloys, however this comes with weight. Aluminum has decrease power however a better strength-to-weight ratio than stainless steel. Consequently, stainless steel parts can function in additional harsh environments.The desk beneath illustrates the properties variations in stainless steel 316  vs aluminum 6061 ;Desk: Stainless Steel Vs Aluminum Properties
PropertyAluminium  Stainless Steel 
GradeEN AW 6061 T4EN 1.4401 (316)
Materials yield power (N/mm²)110220
Younger’s modulus  (N/mm²)70,000200,000
Pressure at fracture  (%)1245
Thermal growth coefficient  (Ok⁻¹)23.2 × 10⁻⁶16 × 10⁻⁶
Thermal conductivity  (W/mK)25016
 
  1. Corrosion Resistance 
Stainless steel is comparatively extra outstanding in resisting corrosion and materials degradation. The chromium content material in stainless steel alloys develops the chromium oxide layer( Cr20 3), which shields the part from exterior environmental elements.
  1. Materials Price
Aluminium is cheaper than stainless steel. The alloying of components like chromium and nickel in excessive quantities ( typically 30+%) decreases the price of stainless steel. Alternatively, aluminium’s price benefit comes from its ample availability and decrease price of uncooked materials and manufacturing processes.
  1. Thermal Conductivity 
Usually, aluminium’s thermal conductivity is increased than that of stainless steel. Nevertheless, stainless steel is extra appropriate if we analyse its makes use of in warmth switch or thermal functions. It may possibly switch warmth by conduction and convection mixed with the appropriate end association.Stainless Steel vs Aluminum: What are the Differences?

CNC Machining: Aluminum Vs Stainless Steel

What are the variations between aluminum and stainless steel machining? There isn’t a straight reply. CNC machining is a posh process. The variations between these metals will be seen in machinability, machining velocity, software materials, warmth buildup, and different areas.If we examine the CNC machinability of stainless steel vs aluminum, stainless steel is more difficult to machine than aluminum when it comes to chopping, milling, turning, drilling, or different operations. The decrease hardness and malleable nature of aluminum make it straightforward to machine. In the meantime, the stainless steel tends to work hardened, making it troublesome to machine. Due to this fact, stainless steel workpieces require particular chopping instruments which can be carbide- or diamond-coated.Desk: Aluminum Vs Stainless Steel Machining 
SideAluminum Machining Stainless Steel Machining 
DeviceCarbide-tipped, Excessive-Velocity Steel (HSS)Carbide, Ceramic, Cobalt-based instruments
Cutting VelocityGreater (150-500 m/min)Decrease (30-100 m/min)
Feed PriceGreater (0.5-2.0 mm/rev)Decrease (0.1-0.5 mm/rev)
As-machined EndGood surface end with minimal effortRequires extra effort to attain a easy end
PriceDecrease materials and machining priceGreater materials and machining price
Utility ExamplesPlane elements, automotive parts, client electronicsSurgical units, kitchenware, marine {hardware}, architectural objects
 

Summing Up 

From this dialogue on stainless steel vs aluminum, we are able to say there isn’t a straight reply for which is healthier aluminum or stainless steel. It solely relies on the parts or merchandise you might be in search of. Stainless steel is appropriate for extra harsh environments and high-stress functions. Alternatively, aluminium is superior for low weight functions requiring good power. Moreover, the choice between aluminum and stainless can also be influenced by your manufacturing process. CNC machining, casting, or every other.At JuSheng, we offer Stainless Steel Machining Companies and Aluminum machining service with superior multi-axis CNC machines. Our observe report of offering stainless steel parts and merchandise throughout industries may also help you get your machining mission performed.JuSheng offers a full range of CNC machining, sheet metal fabrication, 3D printing, injection molding,metal stamping  for your project needs. Visit our Instant Quote Engine to get a free, no-obligation quote in minutes.

Disclaimer

The content appearing on this webpage is for informational purposes only. JuSheng makes no representation or warranty of any kind, be it expressed or implied, as to the accuracy, completeness, or validity of the information. Any performance parameters, geometric tolerances, specific design features, quality and types of materials, or processes should not be inferred to represent what will be delivered by third-party suppliers or manufacturers through JuSheng’s network. Buyers seeking quotes for parts are responsible for defining the specific requirements for those parts. Please contact to our for more information. 

Team JuSheng

This article was written by various JuSheng  contributors. JuSheng is a leading resource on manufacturing with CNC machining, sheet metal fabrication, 3D printing, injection molding,metal stamping and more.

FAQs

Which one ought to I take advantage of, stainless steel or aluminum?The selection relies on your utility necessities. Use aluminum for light-weight, excessive thermal conductivity, and ease of machining. Alternatively, stain steel is right for prime power, glorious corrosion resistance, and sturdiness.Which is stronger, aluminum or stainless steel?Stainless steel is extra sturdy than aluminum, which makes it appropriate for high-stress functions.Is stainless steel extra immune to corrosion than aluminum?Sure, stainless steel is extra corrosion-resistant than aluminum as a result of its chromium content material, which types a protecting oxide layer.What are the benefits of aluminum over stainless steel?Aluminum is lighter, simpler to machine, has increased thermal and electrical conductivity and is cheaper.When to decide on stainless steel over aluminum?Select stainless steel once you want excessive power, superior corrosion resistance, and sturdiness in harsh environments—for instance, medical, marine, meals processing, and architectural elements.
Scroll to Top

Let's build something great
Free quote, fast delivery, high-quality parts!